Episodes

June 5, 2024

62. Lobster Boy - Grady Stiles, Jr.

Since the 1840s the Stiles family had passed down a rare condition called Ectrodactyly that makes the hands look like lobster claws.  Grady Stiles turned his family's condition into a lucrative business performing in the tra…
May 29, 2024

61. The Bitter Blood Murders Pt. 2

Send us a Text Message. On June 3, 1985, police cautiously pursued a Chevy Blazer with four passengers. A slow chase had persisted for several miles-- from Greensboro into Summerfield, North Carolina. Suddenly, the Blazer …
May 22, 2024

60. The Bitter Blood Murders Pt.1

In the years between 1984 and 1985, three intertwined families experienced the murders of close family members.  The murders spanned from Louisville, Kentucky to Winston Salem and Greensboro, NC. Susie Newsome Lynch and Fri…
May 8, 2024

59. The Ballroom Murders

An episode of America's Most Wanted in 1989 showcased the story of John List who killed his entire family - wife, mother, and three children - leaving them in the ballroom of their 19-room mansion. More than one viewer calle…
May 1, 2024

The Martyrdom of John and Betty Stam

In December 1934, a young missionary couple, John and Betty Stam, were beheaded by Communist soldiers in Anhui Province along with a Chinese Christian brother named Chang Shushing. Listen to their story here. Male Narrato…
April 24, 2024

57: The Bloody Benders: Homicidal Homesteaders

As Westward expansion began in the US after the Civil War, homesteaders staked land claims across the plains. One family set up a crude store and Inn along the trail, taking advantage of the location where many a weary trave…
April 17, 2024

56. North Carolina's Killer Baptist Preacher: Reverend George Washington Carawan

Reverend George Washington Carawan was charged and found guilty of the murder of a school teacher named Clement H. Lassiter . After learning the jury had found him guilty and that he would be hanged for his crime, Reverend…
April 10, 2024

55. I'd Kill For a Piece of Chocolate

The seaside town of Brighton, England had a string of poisonings in the late 1870's.  The victims became severely sick after eating chocolate cream candies from a local sweet shop owned by J. G. Maynard. Mr. Maynard rid his …
April 3, 2024

54. The Disappearance and Murder of Alma Kellner

Alma Kellner born in 1901, was the daughter of wealthy brewers in Louisville, Kentucky.On December 8, 1909, Alma disappeared on her way to attend mass at St. John's Roman Catholic Church, not far from her home. At first it w…
March 27, 2024

53. The Burning Bed

Before there were restraining orders and women's shelters galore, domestic violence victims often suffered for years in silence. This is the story of one woman and her final desperate attempt to save herself when she realize…
March 20, 2024

52. Father Hans Schmidt: A Killer Priest

Today's episode is about the life and crimes of Father Hans Schmidt. He was executed in 1916 for murder. Schmidt is the only priest ever to be executed in the United States. Music- Isaiah Hildreth Male Narrator- Curtis Hil…
March 13, 2024

51. Another Fort Bragg Murder

On Mother's Day 1985, a young mother and her two little girls were found dead in their home near Ft. Bragg, NC. The youngest of her daughters was left alive, alone, crying, and dehydrated in her crib waiting for a rescue. Th…
March 6, 2024

50. The Snowden Family Murders

Martha McKay was found murdered on her family property in Horseshoe Lake, Arkansas. Her mother was found murdered on the same property twenty-four years earlier. . Travis Lewis was Martha's killer--the same person convicte…
Feb. 28, 2024

49. The MacDonald Family Murders Pt. 2

In early 1970 Capt. Jeffrey MacDonald is awakened by the screams of his wife and daughters being attacked.  He claims a group of drugged-up hippies were the intruders, but authorities quickly begin to question that claim. Th…
Feb. 21, 2024

48. The MacDonald Family Murders Pt. 1

At the height of the hippie culture and "Satanic Panic" in the early 1970s, a gruesome murder is committed at Fort Bragg, NC.  A pregnant mother and her two small daughters are repeatedly stabbed to death.  Her husband, Capt…
Feb. 14, 2024

47. A Valentine from Belle Gunness

Belle Gunness also known as Hell's Princess was a pig farmer in the early 1900's. She posted help wanted and lonely hearts ads in newspapers--luring men to their deaths with promises of love and wealth. Music By Isaiah Hildr…
Feb. 7, 2024

46. Horror Story on Smuttynose

On March 5, 1873, two women were found brutally axed to death on the secluded Smuttynose Island just off the coast of Maine. Music by Isaiah Hildreth Male Narrator Curtis Hildreth Sources: Mystery on the Isles of Shoals: Clo…
Jan. 24, 2024

45. The Mysterious Death of Smith Reynolds

Accident? Suicide? Or Murder? The question of "Z" Smith Reynolds' death is still not answered to this day more than ninety years later. The wealthy heir of the RJ Reynolds Tobacco fortune was shot on his sleeping porch after…
Jan. 17, 2024

44. Grave Consequences

On March 1, 1922, Tennessee sent four men ( under the age of twenty) to the electric chair to pay with their lives for the life they took. Music by Isaiah Hildreth Male Narrator: Curtis Hildreth Sources: newspapers.com The…
Jan. 10, 2024

43. The Crimes of Georgia Tann

Georgia Tann was a social worker whose crimes spanned three decades from the 1920s to 1950. What appeared to be benevolence on her part was actually greed and downright evil that affected many families during those years. Sh…
Dec. 24, 2023

42. Christmas Eve Special - Lowe Daniels

In 1914, Lowe Daniels lived in the Uwharrie forest. He made his living making and selling whiskey. One day he came home from a trip and out of nowhere, shot his wife, his wife's seventeen year old sister, his seventeen year…
Dec. 20, 2023

41. Serial Killing Mother

In 1966 a father in Georgia died suddenly from an apparent heart attack. He was just 39 years old. Just seven months later his 13-year-old son became sick suddenly and passed away within a short time.  Mysterious deaths cont…
Dec. 13, 2023

40. A Christmas Mystery - What Happened to the Five Sodder Children?

A fire broke out on Christmas Eve night in 1945 at the Sodder house in Fayetteville, West Virginia. Five of the Sodder family's ten children didn't make it outside with the rest of their family. George Sodder, their fath…
Dec. 6, 2023

39. The Boone Bathtub Murders

During a snowstorm in early 1972, a Boone, NC family is shockingly murdered in their own home. At first, it appears to be a robbery gone bad, but upon further inspection, that theory does not seem to add up. It was a crime t…